California Nursing Home Abuse Lawyer Blog

Just before leaving the White House, President Bush enacted a rule that designates state inspectors of nursing homes as federal employees, making it more difficult to obtain evidence obtained by those inspectors in private lawsuits against nursing homes for abuse or neglect, such as those pursued by Walton Law Firm LLP.

The new restriction affects about 16,000 nursing facilities in the United States, and will require litigants to go to greater lengths to obtain information that used to be routinely given. In short, the rule prohibits state health departments (such as the Department of Public Health in California) from participating in private lawsuits that are in the federal assistance program.

Bloomberg.com has more on the story here.

California ombudsman Nona Tolentino's job is to investigate cases of suspected elder abuse in nursing homes. Her conclusion after years as in the business: be afraid, be very afraid.

The biggest problem Tolentino faces is trying to prove the allegations. "I call it the conspiracy of silence," she said, because many nursing home residents and their family are reluctant to talk about, frequently out of concerns of retaliation or being evicted from the facility. Tolentino believes strongly that nursing home residents have fundamental rights to be free from physical and verbal abuse, unnecessary restraints, or involuntary seclusion.

Tolentino is mostly right. If one were to visit the local office of the California Department of Public Health and pull the file of any large nursing home in the region where they lived, they would be startled by the number of complaints made and investigated. More troubling, however, would be the realization that the vast majority of complaints are "unsubstantiated;" meaning the investigator could not prove the allegations are true.

This is a real problem. Not that every complaint is meritorious, but that the investigation and enforcement of these complaints is very inadequate. In our office, we have litigated numerous cases involving horrendous cases of neglect or abuse where a formal state investigation had previously found no wrongdoing. Sadly, because of California's budget woes, this probably will not change anytime soon.

Three California nursing home employees were arrested yesterday for allegedly injecting 22 residents with mood-altering drugs to keep them quiet and restrained. According to the criminal complaint, a nursing director, a pharmacist, and a physician drugged the residents in order to keep them compliant and easier to care for. Three of the patients died.

“These are powerful medications that were given, in some cases against people’s will, primarily for management, not health reasons,” said California Attorney General Jerry Brown. “It's unconscionable behavior and it’s certainly not what people expect when they entrust their parents or grandparents to a skilled nursing home.”

The allegations in the criminal complaint are appalling, including residents becoming "zombie-like" and unable to eat or drink for days, causing severe malnutrition and dehydration. The three residents who died were Fannie May Brinkley, Eddie Dolenc, and Joseph Shepter. At least one civil lawsuit has been filed as a result of the deaths, and more are expected.

The use of powerful narcotics as chemical restraints is an ongoing problem in nursing homes. Under California law, a resident, or his/her responsible party must be thoroughly informed about the risks associated with anti-psychotic medications, and must approve any request for us. These medications must also be administered only with a doctor's order.

Lemon Grove Care and Rehabilitation (San Diego County) has received the state's most severe citation after the burn-injury death of a 74-year-old resident. State investigators found that the facility failed to adequately supervise the resident, who caught fire while smoking at the facility. According the reports, the woman was sitting in the designated smoking area trying to light a cigarette when her jacket caught fire. She died 10 days after suffering her injury.

The nursing home has been issued an "AA" citation and a fine of $80,000.00, which it intends to challenge in Superior Court. Lemon Grove Nursing and Rehabilitation received two Class B citations last year (click here), and is currently under investigation for separate allegations of neglect in a case being handled by Walton Law Firm LLP.

Walton Law Firm LLP represents individuals and families throughout Southern California in cases involving nursing home abuse and neglect. All consultations about a case are free and confidential.

Southern California legislators are supporting a proposal that would require nursing homes to post their ratings on the front door, much like health grades are posted at restaurants. Yesterday, Assembly Bill 215 was introduced in the California legislature to require that any nursing home that receive federal money to prominently display the rating it received under the federal government's recently unveiled five-star rating system.

“Posting nursing home grades is crucial to ensuring our loved ones receive the high quality of care they deserve,” State Representative Mike Feuer (D-Los Angeles) said in a statement. “This legislation will give families valuable information and provide an additional incentive to facilities to achieve the highest standards.”

Last month, Los Angeles County supervisors voted unanimously to require that any nursing facility that receives Medicare and Medi-Cal funding to post their ratings, and inform all new residents of the rating. The ratings are based on federal inspections, using three years worth of data.

To go to the federal ratings website click here.

The attorneys at Walton Law Firm LLP represent individuals and families who have suffered due to abuse or neglect in the nursing home setting. Cases are accepted throughout Southern California.